这篇2019年发表的Molecular Medicine Reports期刊,主要由Yeli Wang , Linsong Mu , Miaoling Huang共同完成,所有作者来自青岛大学医学院附属烟台毓璜顶医院;2020年3月有读者对文章多张图片重复产生质疑,昨天改论文已被撤回
论文信息
标题:MicroRNA?195 suppresses rectal cancer growth and metastasis via regulation of the PI3K/AKT signaling pathway
作者:Yeli Wang, Linsong Mu, Miaoling Huang
期刊:Molecular Medicine Reports
发表日期:2019年11月
DOI:10.3892/mmr.2019.10717
PMID:31702045
PMCID:PMC6797947
质疑内容
#1 Elisabeth M Bik comment accepted March 2020
Figure 2A.
Red boxes. In the 48h row, the "Blank" and "mimic control" panels appear to show an area of overlap.
#2 Elisabeth M Bik comment accepted March 2020
Figure 2B.
Blue boxes: The SW837/Blank panel appears to show an overlap with the SW837/mimic control panel.
Green boxes: The SW837/mimic panel appears to show an overlap with the SW1463/mimic control panel.
Pink box: (see below): The SW1463/mimic panel appears to show an overlap with the SW837/mimic panel in Figure 7A.
#3 Elisabeth M Bik comment accepted March 2020
Figure 7A. Several panels appear to overlap, including one pane that overlaps with Figure 2B above (pink box).
撤回
在上述论文发表后,一位关心的读者提请编辑注意,关于图 2A 所示的划痕测定实验和图 2B 和 7A 所示的细胞侵袭测定实验,大量数据面板显示出数据重叠的证据,无论是在相同的图部分内还是在图 2 和 7 之间的比较中。
由于本文中发现了大量数据重复事件,Molecular Medicine Reports 的编辑决定将其从期刊中撤回,因为对所提供的数据缺乏信心。
作者被要求解释这些担忧,但编辑部没有收到回复。
对于由此造成的任何不便,编辑向读者道歉。
END
Don't be ashamed
专注于国内论文质疑报道
欢迎投稿联系